Our Ice Cream
We didn’t invent ice cream. We just believe it should still be made simply. Somewhere along the way, ice cream stopped being food and became a formula. Gums. Fillers. Ingredients you need a chemistry degree to understand.
Real ice cream starts with real ingredients.
Milk. Cream. Eggs. Maple syrup.
No shortcuts. No unpronounceables. Just thoughtful sourcing, simple recipes, natural goodness. The result: Ice cream that tastes rich, delicious, and real.
It isn’t complicated. It’s just ice cream made right!
The Maple Difference
Sweetness should come from nature, not a factory.
Most ice creams rely on refined sugar to sweeten their products.
We use pure maple syrup. It imparts a deeper sweetness, a richer flavor. A perfect marriage with the other all-natural ingredients that make all our ice cream flavors special.
Our Flavors
Vanilla
Cream, Whole Milk, Pure Maple Syrup, Egg Yolks, Arrowroot Powder, Vanilla Extract
Strawberries & Cream
Cream, Whole Milk, Pure Maple Syrup, Strawberries, Egg Yolks, Arrowroot Powder, Vanilla Extract
Chocolate
Cream, Whole Milk, Pure Maple Syrup, Egg Yolks, Arrowroot Powder, Vanilla Extract, Cocoa Powder
Butter Pecan
Cream, Whole Milk, Pure Maple Syrup, Pecans, Butter, Egg Yolks, Arrowroot Powder, Vanilla Extract
Mint Chocolate Chip
Cream, Whole Milk, Pure Maple Syrup, Egg Yolks, Arrowroot Powder, Vanilla Extract, Unsweetened Chocolate, Peppermint Oil
Coffee
Cream, Whole Milk, Pure Maple Syrup, Egg Yolks, Coffee, Arrowroot Powder, Vanilla Extract
Chocolate Peanut Butter
Cream, Whole Milk, Pure Maple Syrup, Cocoa Powder, Peanut Butter (Peanuts, Salt), Egg Yolks, Arrowroot Powder, Vanilla Extract
Cherry Chocolate Chip
Cream, Whole Milk, Pure Maple Syrup, Cherries, Unsweetened Chocolate, Egg Yolks, Arrowroot Powder, Almond Extract, Vanilla Extract
Where can I buy First Tap Ice Cream?
We are currently focused on expanding and growing First Tap Ice Cream so that we can bring our exceptional treats to a wider market. So we are not offering local delivery or participating in farmers markets at this time.
Please check back for updates! We look forward to making our ice cream available again soon. Your patience will be rewarded!
In the meantime: